Government Seeks More Harvard Admissions Data

Justice Department says it needs proof that Harvard is complying with a 2023 court ruling.

Wrought iron gate with ornate design, flanked by brick pillars and lush greenery.

Gray Gate, one of the entrances to Radcliffe Yard, where Harvard’s admissions office is located. | PHOTOGRAPH BY NIKO YAITANES/hARVARD MAGAZINE

Amid ongoing speculation about the status of settlement talks between Harvard and the Trump administration, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) filed a complaint in court on February 13 seeking “applicant-level” admissions data from Harvard.

The complaint, filed in a U.S. district court, came one week after Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, M.P.P. ’13, announced that the defense department would discontinue graduate-level professional programs for active-duty service members.

In the filing, the DOJ stated that it seeks a “searchable electronic spreadsheet” containing individual-level admissions data. Previously, the government has requested that such data include applicants’ race and ethnicity, the demographics of their high schools and zip codes, grade-point averages, recruited athlete status, employment history, financial aid offerings, interviewer ratings, and internal ratings.

The government says that it “needs applicant-level data to determine whether Harvard is complying with Title VI and the Supreme Court’s ruling” in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard, the 2023 Supreme Court case that banned the consideration of race in admissions decisions. Title VI is a section of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 that prohibits discrimination based on race, color, or national origin in programs and activities that receive federal financial assistance.

In a statement, a Harvard spokesperson said that “Harvard has been responding to the government’s inquiries in good faith and continues to be willing to engage with the government according to the process required by law.”

Harvard changed its admissions practices in response to the Students for Fair Admissions ruling. Admissions team members do not have access to either aggregate or individual race and ethnicity data until after the close of the admissions process. All application readers, including alumni volunteers, are instructed not to ask about or consider an applicant’s race when performing their admissions work. And demographic data about each class is withheld until after the start of that class’s first academic year.

The Harvard College admissions application itself has also changed. Short answer questions no longer ask identity-based questions. Instead, the questions focus on how a student believes they will contribute to the Harvard community. Mandatory standardized testing—helpful in identifying talented students from across the socioeconomic spectrum—was reintroduced in 2024.

Based on data from the undergraduate class of 2029, the percentage of Black students admitted to the College declined for a second straight year this past fall, while the percentage of Asian students increased—both anticipated outcomes of the court ruling.

The government’s February court filing states that “the United States does not accuse Harvard of any discriminatory conduct, nor does it seek monetary damages or the revocation of federal funding.” Citing the absence of individual student data, it asks the court to declare that Harvard has violated its obligations under Title VI and to order Harvard to produce the requested information.

But because the government’s request for individual-level student admissions data from Harvard College, Harvard Medical School, and Harvard Law School involves personally identifiable information, some legal observers have speculated that it might violate student privacy laws.

In the statement, Harvard’s spokesperson added: “The University will continue to defend itself against these retaliatory actions which have been initiated simply because Harvard refused to surrender its independence or relinquish its constitutional rights in response to unlawful government overreach.”

Read more articles by Jonathan Shaw

You might also like

Judge Dismisses Case Demanding Harvard Admissions Data

The government failed to meet procedural requirements before suing the University.

Harvard Stabilizes Finances With Strong Endowment Returns, Philanthropy

Small operating surplus is dwarfed by reduced federal research support and endowment tax liabilities.

Trump Administration Asks Appeals Court to Restore Harvard Funding Cuts

The government’s lawyers homed in on a jurisdictional argument for its authority to to terminate federal grants. 

Most popular

New Names Proposed for Harvard Extension School Degrees

Long pushed for, the changes would be part of a broader rebranding for the Division of Continuing Education.

To Promote Healthy Habits in Patients, Start with the Doctors

Why Harvard Medical School is training physicians to think more like coaches

Harvard Weathers a Year of Turmoil

The federal government has launched unprecedented actions against the University. Here’s a guide.

Explore More From Current Issue

Illuminated hanging sculptures resembling organic forms, casting warm light in a dim space.

Artists Enzo Camacho and Ami Lien turn a colonial symbol from Cambodia inside out.

Delicate green cocoa pods and small white flowers on a tree branch, surrounded by soft greenery.

Harvard researchers investigate climate’s impact on cocoa crops, innovations in nasal vaccines, and links between pain and skull marrow.

Black and white portrait of a woman with medium-length hair, smiling softly.

The outgoing executive director and Harvard Business School graduate went from dancing The Nutcracker to growing a ballet company.