The Framer Who Refused to Sign the Constitution

Harvard’s Elbridge Gerry helped draft the U.S. Constitution, but worried it might create a new monarch.

Portrait of a man with white hair, wearing a black coat, arms crossed, thoughtful expression.

Elbridge Gerry by Nathaniel Jocelyn, c. 1845-1847 | HARVARD ART MUSEUMS/FOGG MUSEUM, LOUISE E. BETTENS FUND

Elbridge Gerry, A.B. 1762, might be best known in history as the namesake of “gerrymandering”—the irregular drawing of legislative districts (based on a bill he signed as governor of Massachusetts). But Gerry was also instrumental in the birth of the United States, from signing the Declaration of Independence to attending the Constitutional Convention of 1787. And he was notable for refusing to sign the Constitution he’d helped shape.

Gerry worried that the document didn’t safeguard the rights of private citizens and left them vulnerable to the power of the executive and the charms of self-interested demagogues. “The people do not want virtue,” he said at the Convention, “but are the dupes of pretended patriots.” He argued successfully for including provisions for impeachment in the Constitution. And his advocacy influenced James Madison’s efforts to ensure the passage of the Bill of Rights—a key check on federal power. Gerry eventually joined Madison’s ticket as the vice presidential candidate in the 1812 election. In 1813, he took the oath of office at Elmwood—his home, and later home to Harvard presidents. 

 

 

Read more articles by Jonathan Shaw

You might also like

A new book explores the Harvard-trained architect’s vision and impact, from Ground Zero to the Smithsonian.

Plus, veteran higher education leader Thomas Ehrlich reflects on university curricula for his 70th reunion

In 2004, a frenzy spread across Harvard Yard in days. Four billion users later, we are only just catching up.

Most popular

Harvard’s Class of 2029 Reflects Shifts in Racial Makeup After Affirmative Action Ends

International students continue to enroll amid political uncertainty; mandatory SATs lead to a drop in applications.

The Harvard graduate’s roundtable talk show touches on hot button issues from religion to sex. 

In 1954, Gregory Corso moved into Eliot House. How he stayed there is a literary legend.

Explore More From Current Issue

Colorful word cloud with various emotions and ideas related to learning and reflection.

But it can’t replace human connection.

Three hands hold smartphones displaying social media profiles with likes and hearts.

Tell us about how social media impacts your daily life.

A glowing bulb shape surrounded by colorful, swirling energy lines against a blue background.

Harvard researchers achieve medical breakthroughs in cancer therapy and infection control.