Court Blocks International Student Visa Rule

Citing improper procedure, a district judge postponed the government’s efforts to cap student visas at four years.

John Harvard statue under the American Flag

PHOTOGRAPH BY NIKO YAITANES/HARVARD MAGAZINE 

A federal rule governing international visas for students, visiting scholars, and journalists, which had been scheduled to take effect on September 15, was stayed this week when a federal judge in the Massachusetts district court issued a preliminary injunction postponing its implementation. The new U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) rule would have capped the length of a standard student visa at four years, and limited students’ ability to leave and reenter the country without reauthorization. Most doctoral degrees require five or more years of study.

In a strongly worded order, U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV, J.D. ’81, wrote that “the weakness of the connection between the rule and its purported rationales raises legitimate questions as to whether its real purpose is not to safeguard national security and protect our borders,” as the government contends, “but to achieve other, undisclosed, goals—such as, for example, asserting greater government control over academic institutions and the press.” That possibility, far from hypothetical, corresponds with two earlier Trump administration actions that Saylor cited in his order: an attempt to revoke Harvard’s authorization to enroll international students, followed by a presidential proclamation that would have prevented foreign students intending to attend Harvard from entering the United States.

The plaintiffs in the case include three organizations that represent a variety of colleges, universities, and educators—including Harvard—and four labor organizations.

The government argued that the rule is needed to safeguard national security, a claim, Saylor wrote, that “borders on the absurd. It is based almost entirely on a small collection of anecdotes,” he continued, “each of which involved incidents that the new rule would do nothing to prevent or even mitigate.”

Saylor nevertheless declined to nullify the challenged regulation, stating, “The role of the judiciary is not to ensure that the executive branch does not make unwise decisions. In this context, at least, the only authority that the Court possesses is to ensure that when the government promulgates a new regulation, it adheres to the law.”

In that regard, Saylor found that the DHS had violated the applicable law—the Administrative Procedure Act—in “multiple respects,” and had failed to consider alternatives or respond to any of the 22,000 public comments on the rule, several of which suggested reasonable alternative solutions.

Furthermore, Saylor ruled, the plaintiffs in the case established that the rule changing the existing “duration of status policy,” which allows student to remain in the United States during their full course of study, would significantly curtail international enrollment at institutions across the U.S., due to the uncertainty it would create among students as to whether they could finish their studies and obtain a degree.

Such declines are occurring already, Saylor noted, citing data on international student withdrawals from the University of Wisconsin-Madison and the University of Maryland, Baltimore, and a 42 percent decline in international student applications to the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.

Saylor’s preliminary injunction postpones the implementation of the rule for now. A hearing before the judge, in which the government is expected to respond, is scheduled for early October.

Read more articles by Jonathan Shaw

You might also like

Judge Dismisses Case Demanding Harvard Admissions Data

The government failed to meet procedural requirements before suing the University.

Harvard Stabilizes Finances With Strong Endowment Returns, Philanthropy

Small operating surplus is dwarfed by reduced federal research support and endowment tax liabilities.

Trump Administration Asks Appeals Court to Restore Harvard Funding Cuts

The government’s lawyers homed in on a jurisdictional argument for its authority to to terminate federal grants. 

Most popular

New Names Proposed for Harvard Extension School Degrees

Long pushed for, the changes would be part of a broader rebranding for the Division of Continuing Education.

Harvard Academic Workers Begin Strike

A second union joined graduate students on the picket line, emptying labs and classrooms.

Harvard Weathers a Year of Turmoil

The federal government has launched unprecedented actions against the University. Here’s a guide.

Explore More From Current Issue

Illustration of a phone, book, hourglass, weights, and a hand reaching for a device on a blue background.

Your thoughts on how to regulate the platforms—and stop using them so much

Collage of three photos of an athlete in a triathlon: one swimming, one cycling, one running, in sports attire.

The Harvard triathlete and coach says she helps normal people to “do extraordinary things.”

A smiling man in a brown plaid suit stands outdoors with greenery in the background.

The professor and former Harvard College dean is the next president of Harvard Magazine’s Board of Directors