Study Finds Effects of Holocaust on Russian Economy and Politics

The Russian regions that lost the most Jews have shown slower economic growth and resistance to political reform, a new study finds.

Nazi germany's occupation of parts of Russia had lasting and quantifiable effects, Florence professor of government James A. Robinson and his coauthors conclude in a working paper published in June by the National Bureau of Economic Research.

Working with Daron Acemoglu of MIT and Tarek A. Hassan of the University of Chicago's Booth School of Business, Robinson spent five years analyzing various data, including census figures and economic measures. The researchers found that the 11 Russian oblasts, or administrative regions, where the Jewish population declined the most—39 percent, on average—between 1939 and 1959 now report per capita GDP figures well below the national average, and that those oblasts showed greater support for preserving the Soviet Union in 1991. These same districts have been more likely to favor Communist candidates since the end of the Soviet Union.

Although Jews were only a small minority of the Soviet population, they played a critical economic role in their societies, Robinson explains. "The Holocaust wiped out many of the most educated and productive people in western Russia," he states in a press release from the Harvard Public Affairs and Communications office. "It was a major shock to the social structure of the invaded regions, dramatically reducing the size of the Russian middle class."

Around one million Soviet Jews are believed to have died in the Holocaust.

For more on Robinson's quantitative approach to studying history, read this magazine's Right Now article "History Quantified," a report on Natural Experiments of History, his book with Jared Diamond ’58.

You might also like

Can We Disagree Better? A Harvard Professor Has Tips.

Kennedy School professor of public policy Julia Minson on how to improve political conversations

Former Homeland Security Chief Says ICE and CBP Have “Lost Their Way”

At Kennedy School talk, Jeh Johnson advocates restructuring “outdated” DHS.

Open Book: A New Nuclear Age

Harvard historian Serhii Plokhy’s latest book looks at the rising danger of a new arms race.

Most popular

Inside Harvard’s Most Egalitarian School

The Extension School is open to everyone. Expect to work—hard.

Harvard’s Productivity Trap

What happened to doing things for the sake of enjoyment?

Ask a Harvard Professor with Francesca Dominici

Discussing the link between air pollution and effects of COVID-19, and the importance of data for rapid public-health responses —with Francesca Dominici, professor of biostatistics at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

Explore More From Current Issue

A woman gazes at large decorative letters with her reflection and two stylized faces beside them.

The True Cost of Grade Inflation at Harvard

How an abundance of A’s created “the most stressed-out world of all.”

Graduates celebrate joyfully, wearing caps and gowns, with some waving and smiling.

Inside Harvard’s Most Egalitarian School

The Extension School is open to everyone. Expect to work—hard.

Modern building surrounded by greenery and a walking path under a blue sky.

A New Landscape Emerges in Allston

The innovative greenery at Harvard’s Science and Engineering Complex