Harvard Magazine Questionnaire: Law in a Lifeboat

Moral philosophers, legal experts, and generations of Harvard students have debated this Victorian-era cannibalism case. Now it’s your turn. 

A vintage compass with cardinal directions marked in black and white.

MONTAge illustration by niko yaitanes/harvard magazine; compass image by pexels

Editor's Note: This survey has closed. You can read the results in the March-April 2026 issue of Harvard Magazine.

animated compass swinging

TEST YOUR MORAL COMPASS
In 1884, the shipwrecked crew of the Mignonette was adrift in a lifeboat for 21 days, with no food or water, before the officers slayed and ate the cabin boy. Moral philosophers and legal experts—and generations of Harvard students—have debated the subsequent murder case. Read the story in Harvard Magazine and join the conversation by filling out the questionnaire below. Responses may be published online and in print.

 

 

 Create your own user feedback survey  

 

Cover story: The 1884 Cannibalism-at-Sea Case That Still Has Harvard Talking

You might also like

Readers Respond to Our ‘Law in a Lifeboat’ Survey

A sampling of answers about a moral dilemma

The 1884 Cannibalism-at-Sea Case That Still Has Harvard Talking

The Queen v. Dudley and Stephens changed the course of legal history. Here’s why it’s been fodder for countless classroom debates.

What Trump Means for John Roberts’s Legacy

Executive power is on the docket at the Supreme Court.

Most popular

The Irresistible Allison Feaster

A basketball star's journey from the Harvard hardwood to the Celtics front office

Harvard Professor Michael Sandel Wins Philosophy’s Berggruen Prize

The creator of the popular ‘Justice’ course receives a $1 million award.

Martin Nowak Placed on Leave a Second Time

Further links to Jeffrey Epstein surface in newly released files

Explore More From Current Issue

A person climbs a curved ladder against a colorful background and four vertical ladders.

Harvard’s Productivity Trap

What happened to doing things for the sake of enjoyment?

Older man in a green sweater holds a postcard in a warmly decorated office.

How a Harvard Hockey Legend Became a Needlepoint Artist

Joe Bertagna’s retirement project recreates figures from Boston sports history.