Bailout: Dividends No, Savings Bonds Yes

In two newspaper op-ed essays, faculty members critique aspects of the federal government's financial-rescue measures and emerging proposals for another economic-stimulus package...

In two newspaper op-ed essays, faculty members critique aspects of the federal government's financial-rescue measures and emerging proposals for another economic-stimulus package.

Writing in the New York Times, in an article titled "This Bailout Doesn't Pay Dividends," David S. Scharfstein (Converse professor of finance and banking at Harvard Business School) and Jeremy C. Stein (Safra professor of economics in the Faculty of Arts and Sciences) argue that the $125 billion invested in banks—with a like sum yet to be invested—should come with a prohibition on payment of dividends to holders of the companies' common stock. By making a preferred-stock investment without imposing such a ban, the authors write, Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson "is described as playing the role of the Godfather, making the banks an offer they could not refuse. But in one important respect, he was more Santa Claus than Vito Corleone": given that the government investments are made to shore up the banks' capital, they argue, it makes no sense to let that capital be dissipated in common-stock dividends (to the tune of an estimated $25 billion annually). During the government bailout of Chrysler, they note, such dividend payments were suspended from 1980 to 1983.

Separately, in the Washington Post, Peter Tufano (Coleman professor of financial management and senior associate dean for planning and University affairs at Harvard Business School ) writes "Just Keep Our Money." Rather than stimulate the economy by sending a new round of checks to taxpayers and consumers, he suggests that the government distribute savings bonds, a tactic by which lawmakers "could help quell the recent chaos, raise as much as $250 billion a year, strengthen families and enhance civic engagement," all while promoting saving. The suggestion arises from work done by the Doorways to Dreams Fund, a nonprofit group that Tufano co-founded to promote saving among lower-income citizens; it has experimented with helping willing families capture their income-tax refunds for savings.

You might also like

Why America’s Strategy For Reducing Racial Inequality Failed

Harvard professor Christina Cross debunks the myth of the two-parent Black family.

At Harvard, Mike Pence Discusses Democracy and Conservatism

The former vice president denounces political violence, expresses hope for a deal between Trump and the University.

Is the Constitution Broken?

Harvard legal scholars debate the state of our founding national document.

Most popular

What Trump Means for John Roberts’s Legacy

Executive power is on the docket at the Supreme Court.

The Harvard Professor Who Quantified Democracy

Erica Chenoweth’s data shows how—and when—authoritarians fall.

The Origins of Europe’s Most Mysterious Languages

A small group of Siberian hunter-gatherers changed the way millions of Europeans speak today.

Explore More From Current Issue

Two small cast iron pans with berry-topped desserts, dusted with powdered sugar, alongside lemon slices.

Shopping for New England-made gifts this Holiday Season

Ways to support regional artists, designers, and manufacturers 

A vibrant composition of flowers, a bird, and butterflies with a distant manor under a moody sky.

Rachel Ruysch’s Lush (Still) Life

Now on display at the Museum of Fine Arts, a Dutch painter’s art proved a treasure trove for scientists.