Harvard library restructuring presages smaller workforce

Library leaders tell staff that restructuring will require smaller workforce.

Widener Library

Widener Library

The changing information landscape makes change at Harvard Library—the world's preeminent academic research library—inevitable. As part of the Harvard Library’s ongoing transition to a new organizational structure—in which many library services will be shared, and for which overarching information technology priorities have been identified—senior library administrators updated staff members on the process in three town-hall-style meetings on Thursday, January 19. (The Library has released an official transcript of the presentation.) In their comments, senior associate provost Mary Lee Kennedy and executive director for the library Helen Shenton announced that they would make specific restructuring recommendations to the library board on January 24. They explained that the changes would involve the elimination of some positions, significant changes to other positions, and the creation of new positions, and specified, in Shenton’s words, “A key change: the Library workforce will be smaller than it is now.”

News of the impending staffing cuts—including inaccurate reports that all staff had, in effect, been fired and would be required to reapply for their jobs—spread quickly through social-media sites and caused consternation among librarians at other research libraries. Stanford University’s assistant librarian, Chris Bourg, blogged that the general sentiment on Twitter was “that the town hall meetings produced more questions than answers” and that “rather than keeping staff informed, they served primarily to created [sic] significant anxiety.” More broadly, “Plenty of folks are worried that as Harvard goes, so go other academic libraries,” she wrote—“in other words, if massive layoffs can happen at Harvard (with its huge endowments), then no academic library is safe.”

Shenton and Kennedy also told library staff members that they hoped to be able to share more details of the restructuring at follow-up meetings in mid February. Their inability to provide more specifics during the question-and-answer periods that followed their presentations left many attendees frustrated. Inevitably, the process was compared unfavorably to a similar restructuring that took place at the Harvard Law School Library (HLSL) from 2008 to 2009, in which a steering committee made up of nine union and professional staff members led the change from within and worked to create as transparent a process as possible.

The University-wide restructuring, by contrast, is described by “many HLSL employees” (according to a Harvard Graduate School of Education case study of the HLSL restructuring) as “closed,” “dark,” and “bureaucratic”—perhaps inevitable for such a large-project: 73 separate libraries are involved. As one staffer who attended the January 19 presentation told Harvard Magazine, “One of the things that is different about the University-wide reorganization is that we are sorely lacking John [Palfrey]'s vision and communicable enthusiasm at this point.” Palfrey, Ess Librarian at HLSL, “did a lot of the heavy lifting in selling this process during the first half of the library transition, and since his announcement that he was leaving Harvard, I think our leadership has been floundering.…These changes need to be sold to us in order to work, and right now they are failing to sell them….”

At the meetings, staff members were encouraged to fill out employee profiles that will include job preferences, a description of skills, and a résumé. Employees also learned that the head of their local library unit would be able to tell them by mid February whether their jobs would be considered part of shared services—and therefore subject to centralized streamlining—or part of the local library, in which case staffing decisions would be up to the discretion of the dean of the school in which the library is embedded.

 The new structure, with staffing changes in place, is expected to launch in July.

You might also like

Harvard Academic Workers Call Off Strike

The union continues bargaining for a contract as members return to work, while graduate students, still on strike, agree to mediation.

Judge Vacates Trump Administration Limit on International Student Visas

Harvard was in a group of plaintiffs that filed suit against the rule in August.

Harvard Academic Workers Begin Strike

A second union joined graduate students on the picket line, emptying labs and classrooms.

Most popular

These Harvard Graduates Are Candidates for Sainthood

For advocacy and benevolence, three late alumni are reportedly in line for the Catholic Church’s highest honor.

New Names Proposed for Harvard Extension School Degrees

Long pushed for, the changes would be part of a broader rebranding for the Division of Continuing Education.

Six from Harvard Named Rhodes Scholars

Four Americans and two Canadians will begin studies at Oxford next fall.

Explore More From Current Issue

Ancient Egyptian painted sarcophagus with detailed hieroglyphs and a woman's face.

A rare Egyptian mummy case is on display at the Harvard Museum of the Ancient Near East.

Collage of three photos of an athlete in a triathlon: one swimming, one cycling, one running, in sports attire.

The Harvard triathlete and coach says she helps normal people to “do extraordinary things.”

Delicate green cocoa pods and small white flowers on a tree branch, surrounded by soft greenery.

Harvard researchers investigate climate’s impact on cocoa crops, innovations in nasal vaccines, and links between pain and skull marrow.