Negatively Curved Crystals

A Harvard mathematician’s “interwoven tapestries” help make the infinite visible.

Curtis McMullen's prints hang in the Science Center lobby
Curtis McMullen's prints hang in the Science Center lobby. 
Photograph by Drew Pendergrass

In Norman Juster’s children’s book The Phantom Tollbooth, the land of infinity can be reached by following a line drawn on the ground for all eternity, then taking a left at the end. Fortunately, for viewers in a hurry, an exhibition now on display on the first floor of the Science Center offers a shortcut. Cabot professor of mathematics, Curtis McMullen, chair of the department, has created a series of nine prints, Negatively Curved Crystals, in part to illustrate how research mathematics sees the infinite. For mathematicians, McMullen’s images are themselves discoveries—as much a part of the research process as the proof of a new theorem. For everyone else, these prints are beautiful works of art, interwoven tapestries of lines and curves that build slowly into shadowy geometric forms, some only visible at a distance. Each image is the trace of an infinite process, left behind for us finite beings to admire.

McMullen began drawing images like these with a computer program he wrote in the 1990s—his colleagues had been imagining certain mathematical patterns for years, proving facts about their structure and form, but had never seen them with their own eyes. Each print in the exhibition is generated from a geometric rule, some simple enough to be familiar to any avid doodler. Although I didn’t recognize the name, when I saw McMullen’s rendition of what mathematicians call the “Apollonian Gasket,” I felt an immediate spark of recognition: I drew the same thing out of boredom in one of my high-school notebooks. The image is a fractal, meaning that you can zoom in infinitely far on parts of the image and still see similar patterns emerge. McMullen created the print by packing smaller and smaller circles together in vanishing free space, creating an intricate pattern out of a basic notebook game. 


Image by Curtis McMullen

When McMullen talks about mathematics, I get the feeling that he sees it all a bit like a Bach suite: endless variations twirling around a simple theme. Inspired by the basic print above, where the circles all touch each other at a point, McMullen wanted to see a portrait of interwoven circles where none of them touch at all—an infinitely complex circular slice of Swiss cheese. “People knew mathematically that these patterns should exist, but they had never seen one before,” he explains. “So, for me, this was like discovering something or visualizing a new physical or astronomical phenomenon.” He blew the pattern up onto a sphere, a bit like a celestial globe displaying the constellations in the night sky.


Image by Curtis McMullen

Each of the other prints follows its own internal set of rules. Many are generated by a simple pattern of lines reflected many times, the way two mirrors across from one another create the appearance of a tunnel extending infinitely far into the distance. All share a complex relationship to what mathematicians call “negatively  curved space”—an exotic place where normal geometric rules like the Pythagorean theorem no longer apply. But despite all the mathematical rigor behind his prints, McMullen has decided against explaining how he created the images in his exhibition. “People often have a negative reaction to the word ‘mathematics,’ right? I didn't want to push that it was mathematics. I didn't want to say what it was at all,” he says. “I just wanted it to be something for people to look at and discuss.” Some viewers have told him that his prints resemble rugs, or X-ray crystallography, or shorelines viewed from an airplane—an ambiguity McMullen enjoys.


Image by Curtis McMullen

Like many artists, McMullen seems drawn to creating things—as if he has no choice but to build intricate patterns out of curves. As he tells it, the print series was a kind of outlet for this restless process of creation. “I was putting them on my refrigerator; I was putting them on the bulletin board; and I wondered how I could exorcise this from my life,” he says. 

Read more articles by: Drew Pendergrass

You might also like

“It’s Tournament Time”

Harvard women’s basketball prepares for Ivy Madness.

A Harvard Agenda Shaped by Speech

The work underway in the Faculty of Arts and Sciences

Dialogue, not Debate

American University’s Lara Schwartz, J.D. ’98, teaches productive disagreement.

Most popular

alt text here

AWOL from Academics

Behind students' increasing pull toward extracurriculars

Lola Mullaney, Coach Carrie Moore, and Elena Rodriguez

“It’s Tournament Time”

Harvard women’s basketball prepares for Ivy Madness.

View of Harvard University campus from the Charles River

Why Americans Love to Hate Harvard

The president emeritus on elite universities’ academic accomplishments—and a rising tide of antagonism

More to explore

Winthrop Bell

Brief life of a philosopher and spy: 1884-1965

Talking about Talking

Fostering healthy disagreement

A Dogged Observer

Novelist and psychiatrist Daniel Mason takes the long view.