Tenure Travails

During the 2003-2004 academic year, the Faculty of Arts and Sciences (FAS) extended 32 tenure offers, just four of them to women (only one of...

During the 2003-2004 academic year, the Faculty of Arts and Sciences (FAS) extended 32 tenure offers, just four of them to women (only one of whom accepted). Citing those figures — and a steady decline in the proportion of offers made to women since 1999 to 2001, when more than one-third of the candidates sought as FAS professors were women — 26 tenured men and women wrote a detailed letter of concern to President Lawrence H. Summers and FAS dean William C. Kirby in mid June. The letter and the replies, dated July 23, were leaked to Science in mid September, prompting broad debate on the faculty's makeup.

The FAS professors' letter emphasized the importance of "statements from university leaders that regularly affirm a strong institutional commitment" to diversity. Summers stressed that "our recruitment process [must] not be hindered by failures of energy, imagination, or openness," and focused on "increasing the fraction of departmental offers that go to women." Kirby addressed departmental processes, too, and outlined "extra-departmental mechanisms," driven by his new divisional academic deans, to prompt progress.

All the parties were to discuss matters further on October 6, after this issue went to press; a full report will appear in the January-February issue of this magazine.      

Most popular

Mark Carney on the Limits of Soft Power

At the 2026 Davos summit, the Canadian prime minister echoes Harvard’s Joseph Nye.

Why Men Are Falling Behind in Education, Employment, and Health

Can new approaches to education address a growing gender gap?

A Flu Vaccine That Actually Works

Next-gen vaccines delivered directly to the site of infection are far more effective than existing shots.

Explore More From Current Issue

An axolotl with a pale body and pink frilly gills, looking directly at the viewer.

Regenerative Biology’s Baby Steps

What axolotl salamanders could teach us about limb regrowth

A girl sits at a desk, flanked by colorful, stylized figures, evoking a whimsical, surreal atmosphere.

The Trouble with Sidechat

No one feels responsible for what happens on Harvard’s anonymous social media app.

A bald man in a black shirt with two book covers beside him, one titled "The Magicians" and the other "The Bright Sword."

Novelist Lev Grossman on Why Fantasy Isn’t About Escapism

The Magicians author discusses his influences, from Harvard to King Arthur to Tolkien.