A Controversial Critique of Teaching and Learning at Harvard

A recent essay by John H. Summers, now a visiting scholar at Boston College's Boisi Center for Religion and American Public Life, has prompted sharp comment among academic readers...

recent essay by John H. Summers, now a visiting scholar at Boston College's Boisi Center for Religion and American Public Life, has prompted sharp comment among academic readers.

Writing in Times Higher Education (a London-based magazine), Summers discusses the six years he spent teaching and advising Harvard undergraduates in the social studies concentration, and the picture he paints is not favorable.

He casts his students as "the post-pubescent children of notables," and writes that they "had already embraced the perspectives of the rich, the powerful and the unalienated, and they seemed to have done so with appalling ease."

Summers writes that he learned soon after arriving at Harvard that although the formal grading scale runs from A to F, "the tacit scale runs from A to B." He describes parents who lobbied to change a grade he had given on a senior oral exam and students who "send gifts to high-placed academic directors." And he asks: "When intellectuals act as clerks and students act as clients, how do college teachers differ from corporate accountants?"

The essay, All the Privileged Must Have Prizes, ran on July 10, but a contentious discussion is still ongoing in the "comments" section at the bottom of the page. Contributors include people who have taught and learned at Harvard (or at least claim to have done so).

Related topics

You might also like

Your Views on Harvard’s Standoff, Antisemitism, and More

Readers comment on the controversial July-August cover, authoritarianism, and scientific research.

Why Harvard Needs International Students

An ed school professor on why global challenges demand global experiences

Free Speech, the Bomb—and Donald Trump

A Harvard cardiologist on the unlikely alliances that shaped a global movement to prevent nuclear war

Most popular

Two Years of Doxxing at Harvard

What happens when students are publicly named and shamed for their views?

A New Narrative of Civil Rights

Political philosopher Brandon Terry’s vision of racial progress

How MAGA Went Mainstream at Harvard

Trump, TikTok, and the pandemic are reshaping Gen Z politics.

Explore More From Current Issue

Room filled with furniture made from tightly rolled newspaper sheets.

A Paper House in Massachusetts

The 1920s Rockport cottage reflects resourceful ingenuity.

Vivian W. Rong sitting on bench outdoors.

Highlighting Harvard Magazine’s Fellows

The 2025-2026 Ledecky and Summer Undergraduate Fellows

Karla Cornejo Villavicencio smiling beside the pink cover of her novel "Catalina" featuring a jeweled star and eye.

Being Undocumented in America

Karla Cornejo Villavicencio’s writing aims to challenge assumptions.