A Controversial Critique of Teaching and Learning at Harvard

A recent essay by John H. Summers, now a visiting scholar at Boston College's Boisi Center for Religion and American Public Life, has prompted sharp comment among academic readers...

recent essay by John H. Summers, now a visiting scholar at Boston College's Boisi Center for Religion and American Public Life, has prompted sharp comment among academic readers.

Writing in Times Higher Education (a London-based magazine), Summers discusses the six years he spent teaching and advising Harvard undergraduates in the social studies concentration, and the picture he paints is not favorable.

He casts his students as "the post-pubescent children of notables," and writes that they "had already embraced the perspectives of the rich, the powerful and the unalienated, and they seemed to have done so with appalling ease."

Summers writes that he learned soon after arriving at Harvard that although the formal grading scale runs from A to F, "the tacit scale runs from A to B." He describes parents who lobbied to change a grade he had given on a senior oral exam and students who "send gifts to high-placed academic directors." And he asks: "When intellectuals act as clerks and students act as clients, how do college teachers differ from corporate accountants?"

The essay, All the Privileged Must Have Prizes, ran on July 10, but a contentious discussion is still ongoing in the "comments" section at the bottom of the page. Contributors include people who have taught and learned at Harvard (or at least claim to have done so).

Sub topics

You might also like

This is How Universities Die

Higher ed thrived in Berlin and Beijing. Then government stepped in. 

Voices Raised about Harvard

Responses to the University’s rejection of federal proposals for intrusive regulation of academic affairs

Yesterday’s News

Seniors’ uncertain future c. 1940, Harvard Law Review news, and more

Most popular

Harvard Layoffs Continue, with More to Come

In the wake of federal government actions, several Harvard schools and institutes are cutting costs.

Are Noncitizens’ Speech Rights Protected?

Harvard faculty testify in a federal lawsuit over free speech and deportations.

Trump Administration Threatens Harvard’s Accreditation, Subpoenas Student Records

The federal government mounts pressure amid negotiations with Harvard.

Explore More From Current Issue

David Leo Rice on 'The Berlin Wall'

David Leo Rice explores the strange, unseen forces shaping our world.

How Harvard Students Handle Political Disagreements

The Undergraduate asks if intellectualism is really on life support.

Filmmaker John Armstrong’s Adventure Documentaries

Filmmaker John Armstrong’s “outdoor adventures” find the human spirit.