Troubadour style dagger from France in Harvard Art Museums described

Is this a dagger which I see before me…? Not primarily.

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Purchased through the generosity of Mariot Fraser Solomon in Memory of Arthur K. Solomon, 2003.240. Photograph by Harvard Art Museums/©President and Fellows of Harvard College

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Purchased through the generosity of Mariot Fraser Solomon in Memory of Arthur K. Solomon, 2003.240. Photograph by Harvard Art Museums/©President and Fellows of Harvard College

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Purchased through the generosity of Mariot Fraser Solomon in Memory of Arthur K. Solomon, 2003.240. Photograph by Harvard Art Museums/©President and Fellows of Harvard College

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Purchased through the generosity of Mariot Fraser Solomon in Memory of Arthur K. Solomon, 2003.240. Photograph by Harvard Art Museums/©President and Fellows of Harvard College

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Purchased through the generosity of Mariot Fraser Solomon in Memory of Arthur K. Solomon, 2003.240. Photograph by Harvard Art Museums/©President and Fellows of Harvard College

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Purchased through the generosity of Mariot Fraser Solomon in Memory of Arthur K. Solomon, 2003.240. Photograph by Harvard Art Museums/©President and Fellows of Harvard College

Although its steel blade is sharp and pointed and capable of doing serious damage unsheathed, this 131/2-inch dagger was not meant to be a weapon. It is French, of cast bronze with gilded silver and engraved steel, and was crafted by an unidentified artist working sometime in the 1840s. Ivan Gaskell, Winthrop curator in the Harvard Art Museums, acquired the piece for the Fogg Museum in 2003 from David and Constance Yates, New York City dealers who specialize in nineteenth-century French sculpture.

Of extremely high quality, the dagger is, says Gaskell, “a wonderful product of the Troubadour movement in the arts in France in the years following the restoration of the monarchy: a Romantic fascination with medieval and Renaissance forms and myths. The movement was multimedia. Napoleon recognized the Middle Ages in the forms of his coronation. Ancient chivalric romances were published in adaptations by the Comte de Tressan and contributed to the rise of the troubadour style. In painting, the style showed up most often in realistic depictions of edifying historical events in smooth finishes and vibrant colors.” Think of some of Ingres’s paintings, Gaskell suggests, such as The Death of Leonardo da Vinci (1818) in the Louvre, in which the French king, Francis I, holding the dying Leonardo, “conspicuously wears a sword that might have accompanied the Fogg dagger.” Gaskell was drawn to the dagger because “it fits in with the Fogg’s early nineteenth-century French paintings and drawings, by Ingres in particular.”

The dagger evokes a Romantic mythology of the Renaissance most melodramatically by personifying Invidia, or Envy, one of the seven deadly sins, her legs and hair intertwined with serpents, in a manner that goes back to Giotto’s depiction of Envy in a fresco in the Arena Chapel in Padua, says Gaskell. Dedicated in 1305, the private chapel was built at the direction of the wealthy moneylender Enrico Scrovegnia, perhaps in penitence for his father’s sins, perhaps for his own. Enrico’s father is the usurer encountered by Dante in the seventh circle of Hell. 

Personifications of virtues and vices, such as this one of Envy, Gaskell adds, were further articulated by handbooks of depictions derived from classical models (Roman coins, for example), by sixteenth-century compilers such as Cesare Ripa. A cook and butler for Cardinal Anton Maria Salviati and an aesthetician in his spare time, Ripa was later knighted for his influential emblem book, Iconologia, which gave allegorical substance to concepts and was quoted by painters, sculptors, poets, and orators for many years.

Gaskell mentions the French Romantic fascination with Shakespeare in general (“Think of Eugène Delacroix, who illustrated various of the poet’s works”). Here, Macbeth springs to mind: “Is this a dagger which I see before me, /The handle toward my hand? Come, let me clutch thee.” The dagger’s “self-referentiality—the personification plunges a dagger into herself—is,” says Gaskell, “a wonderful play on the susceptibility of a contemporary to imagine himself or herself taking on—horrifyingly—the attributes of Envy as he or she grasps the handle! It’s a pure artwork in that sense, not an embellished weapon, though it has the appearance of one.” 

Read more articles by Christopher Reed

You might also like

As Union Protests Continue, Stephen Colbert and Yo-Yo Ma Event at Harvard Cut Short

A conversation between the comedian and the celebrated cellist was interrupted by a fire alarm in Sanders Theatre.

Keri Russell Calls ‘The Diplomat’ a Love Letter to Public Servants

A Harvard Kennedy School event looks behind the scenes of the Netflix drama. 

Boston Ballet’s Ming Min Hui on Changing Audiences and Timothée Chalamet

The outgoing executive director and Harvard Business School graduate went from dancing The Nutcracker to growing a ballet company.

Most popular

New Names Proposed for Harvard Extension School Degrees

Long pushed for, the changes would be part of a broader rebranding for the Division of Continuing Education.

Harvard Academic Workers Begin Strike

A second union joined graduate students on the picket line, emptying labs and classrooms.

Remembering Judge Richard A. Posner

Contributing editor Lincoln Caplan’s 2015 feature of the prolific judge

Explore More From Current Issue

Colorful icons representing sleep, fruit, speech, and a mind with a water lily.

Take this quiz on six healthy habits that Harvard doctors recommend

Collage of three photos of an athlete in a triathlon: one swimming, one cycling, one running, in sports attire.

The Harvard triathlete and coach says she helps normal people to “do extraordinary things.”

Colorful illustration of a split-level house showing various activities in different rooms.

Can the College do more to prepare students for the real world?