Ethics and Human Cells

tktktktk

Return to main article:

“Harvard has been heavily involved in promoting regulatory oversight” of the use of human embryonic stem cells in research, says Insoo Hyun, director of the Center for Life Sciences and Public Learning at Boston’s Museum of Science and an affiliate of Harvard Medical School’s Center for Bioethics. Now, the importance of effective regulatory oversight matters more than ever, as burgeoning research into embryo models, which attempt to mimic the development of real embryos even though they are not derived from the fertilization of an egg, become a feature of laboratory science.

Through the Harvard Embryonic Stem Cell Research Oversight (ESCRO) committee and faculty leadership of organizations such as the International Society for Stem Cell Research (ISSCR), the University has been a leader in formulating and implementing ethical safeguards for the use of these cells. The ISSCR’s research guidelines have evolved in response to the changing scientific landscape, with significant revisions in 2006, 2008, 2016, and 2021. The stem-cell aggregates created in the Ramanathan lab, according to the 2021 vocabulary, are considered “non-integrated embryo models.” The term “non-integrated,” explains Hyun, “means that it is not the whole embryo that is being modeled.”

The vocabulary used to describe these models has evolved with the science. Because stem cells are routinely used to derive cell types that recapitulate organ development, the term “organoid” often appears in scientific papers. A more descriptive term, coined by Haas Foundations professor of linguistics Gennaro Chierchia during a 2018 discussion of nomenclature with Ann Kiessling (a member of the ESCRO committee and formerly an associate professor at Harvard Medical School), is “cellorg,” to denote an organ created from cells. Ramanathan uses the phrase “organized aggregate of stem cell derivatives that undergo morphogenesis” to describe his self-organizing neck-down models of the human body plan. (Ramanathan has chosen not to model the development of the head for ethical reasons.)

Non-integrated embryo models like Ramanathan’s do not require full committee review, according to the latest ISSCR guidelines. Harvard’s policy is to assess the moral and ethical dimensions of research using human embryonic stem cells on a case-by-case basis as part of a dialogue between researchers and the ESCRO committee. That group includes a legal expert, at least one bioethicist, a stem-cell scientist, a developmental biologist, an expert in artificial reproduction, and representatives from outside the University with relevant experience.

Though the terminology used to describe research sometimes becomes a battleground, the real question, says Hyun, is whether a model of an embryo carries moral weight. Often, sentience is the litmus test, which requires a brain. But there are other considerations. In Ramanathan’s case, his ability to reliably create large numbers of non-integrated embryo models is a “great step scientifically,” Hyun says, because it enables “outstanding experiments and has practical applications in drug development and industry.” At the same time, that “mass scale potential for creation,” he continues, could make some people uncomfortable. There’s that “fine line of wanting to do a lot of good by making tools to move forward scientifically and medically,” but weighed against “not wanting to over-instrumentalize or over-commercialize the human body….”

Read more articles by Jonathan Shaw
Related topics

You might also like

This Astronomer is Sounding a Warning on 'Space Junk'

As debris accumulates in low Earth orbit, the danger of destructive collisions continues to rise.

Isaac Kohlberg to Step Down as Head of Harvard Technology Development

Partnerships and licensing office could become more critical as funding cuts loom

A Space-Age Project for Harvard’s Plant Collection

Light-based analysis of botanical collections link plants to Earth’s changing climate.

Most popular

The Professor Who Quantified Democracy

Erica Chenoweth’s data shows how—and when—authoritarians fall.

Remembering Tom Lehrer

The mathematician and satirist kept Harvard in his thoughts—and lyrics

Harvard Layoffs Continue, with More to Come

In the wake of federal government actions, several Harvard schools and institutes are cutting costs.

Explore More From Current Issue

a couple sitting at a park overlooking the ocean

Enjoying Boston Harbor’s Renaissance this summer

Grid of headshots showing newly elected Harvard Overseers and Directors, with names and titles listed below each photo.

Alumni showed increased interest in this year’s elections.

Alexander Gardner’s 1868 photo shows federal peace commissioners with Sophie Mousseau, the lone woman at center.

The wealth gap, shamanism, the life of David Nathan, and more