Civil Discourse and Institutional Neutrality Task Forces

Two Harvard working groups assess constructive dialogue, institutional voice

From left: Tomiko Brown-Nagin, Noah Feldman, Eric Beerbohm, Alison Simmons

From left: Tomiko Brown-Nagin, Noah Feldman, Eric Beerbohm, Alison Simmons |  photographs From left: rose lincoln, stephanie mitchell, stephanie mitchell, rose lincoln; montage by niko yaitanes/harvard magazine

Alan M. Garber, interim president since January 2, and John F. Manning, interim provost since March 14, today announced a pair of University-wide working groups. The “Institutional Voice Working Group” will consider when and if Harvard should take public positions on political issues. The “Open Inquiry and Constructive Dialogue Working Group” will examine how the University can foster civil discourse on campus.

When Garber named Manning interim provost last month, he tasked Manning with tackling both institutional voice and civil discourse. After Harvard’s wavering statements following Hamas’ October 7 terrorist attack on Israel initiated campus chaos, the University began to consider adopting a position of institutional neutrality (first reported by the Harvard Crimson). And after a fall of convulsive campus protests, this spring, the University has focused on fostering respectful disagreement. The College hosted an undergraduate civil discourse summit, and the Kennedy School released a thorough analysis of its speech climate.

In their initial announcement, Garber and Manning appointed a pair of professors to lead the Institutional Voice Working Group: Frankfurter professor of law Noah Feldman and Wolcott professor of philosophy Alison Simmons. The group, the announcement says, will “recommend concrete answers to questions such as: Should the University make official, institutional declarations about matters of social and political significance? Who is authorized to speak for the University on these issues, and how?” Some of these issues were debated at a recent Radcliffe Institute forum, reported here.

The Open Inquiry and Constructive Dialogue Working Group will be led by Eric Beerbohm, director of the Safra Center for Ethics and faculty dean of Quincy House, and Radcliffe Dean Tomiko Brown-Nagin. Both have already worked on leading difficult conversations, Beerbohm as the Faculty of Arts and Sciences’ senior adviser on civil discourse, and Brown-Nagin through her role at Radcliffe. Garber and Manning say this group will examine “how to foster engagement across differing viewpoints as we teach, learn, and interact more broadly with one another throughout the University.”

Garber and Manning write that these groups are “critical to the success of Harvard’s mission of teaching, learning, and research,” and continue:

Success in pursuing this core mission is dependent on free, open, and constructive discourse among the University’s many members. Excellence in discovery and learning requires the ability to advance ideas and explore them fully, to challenge accepted wisdom, to disagree productively, and to recognize that we will often make mistakes as we learn. It is the University’s unwavering commitment to academic freedom and the free exchange of ideas that makes all of this possible.

The full task force memberships are detailed here.

Read more articles by Max J. Krupnick

You might also like

Judge Vacates Trump Administration Limit on International Student Visas

Harvard was in a group of plaintiffs that filed suit against the rule in August.

New Names Proposed for Harvard Extension School Degrees

Long pushed for, the changes would be part of a broader rebranding for the Division of Continuing Education.

Harvard Academic Workers Begin Strike

A second union joined graduate students on the picket line, emptying labs and classrooms.

Most popular

Five from Harvard Named Rhodes Scholars

Four Americans and one Canadian will begin studies at Oxford next fall.

These Harvard Graduates Are Candidates for Sainthood

For advocacy and benevolence, three late alumni are reportedly in line for the Catholic Church’s highest honor.

How Philosophy at Harvard Saved Itself

As humanities shrink across higher education, one department is flourishing. Is its success a fluke, or a roadmap?

Explore More From Current Issue

Black and white portrait of a woman with medium-length hair, smiling softly.

The outgoing executive director and Harvard Business School graduate went from dancing The Nutcracker to growing a ballet company.

Delicate green cocoa pods and small white flowers on a tree branch, surrounded by soft greenery.

Harvard researchers investigate climate’s impact on cocoa crops, innovations in nasal vaccines, and links between pain and skull marrow.

A smiling man in a brown plaid suit stands outdoors with greenery in the background.

The professor and former Harvard College dean is the next president of Harvard Magazine’s Board of Directors